Once, a few years back, I was having some career trouble.
I was working for a publication, performing the duties of the top level editor — who had been dismissed — but, still, my title was “assistant editor.” I was being paid accordingly.
I’d been lobbying for a new title, one that reflected my actual responsibilities, as well as a pay increase. But my boss had been stonewalling. At one point, he promised an answer by a specific Friday. When that day came, I approached my boss and asked for his decision. He said he wanted to think about it some more.
So I phoned my grandmother, a communications expert, and asked for her advice.
She said that if I was up for it, I should write my boss a simple, straightforward note: “The delay doesn’t work for me.”
I was just angry enough to do it. I thought I might be fired, but also, I knew that I wasn’t being treated respectfully, and I needed to do something to change the dynamic.
I left the note for my boss on a Friday. When I walked in Monday, he had cleared out the files — he thought I was quitting. When I assured him that I wasn’t, he demanded to know what I meant by my note.
“I mean: The delay does not work for me,” I said. (I was nothing if not well-coached by my grandmother.)
He blinked. “Oh,” he said.
Then he put down the files. Within the hour, I had a new title and a pay raise.
Perhaps it’s this penchant for spot-on communication advice that prompted me to call her today, to get her take on the state of the election campaign, particularly regarding the latest McCain-Palin incitements.
I reached her in the hospital, where she has been the past two days, being treated for an irregular heart beat. If I was concerned that perhaps she’d been isolated from politics in her convalescence, I needn’t have been. Within a minute, she’d asked me if I’d read the David Brooks column in the Times this morning.
I had, I told her. The one-time McCain supporter appears to have reached a tipping point:
This year could have changed things. The G.O.P. had three urbane presidential candidates. But the class-warfare clichés took control. Rudy Giuliani disdained cosmopolitans at the Republican convention. Mitt Romney gave a speech attacking “eastern elites.” (Mitt Romney!) John McCain picked Sarah Palin.
Palin is smart, politically skilled, courageous and likable. Her convention and debate performances were impressive. But no American politician plays the class-warfare card as constantly as Palin. Nobody so relentlessly divides the world between the “normal Joe Sixpack American” and the coastal elite.
“I have to tell you,” Grandma said, “all the nurses here — I say to them, ‘I’m thinking of voting for Obama,’ and they say: ‘I’m voting for him!’ That’s good.”
She went on to explain that she thinks Obama is going to be somewhat inoculated to these latest attacks, because this stuff has been discussed before.
But, in typical Grandma fashion, she’s got some advice for Sen. Obama:
“My gut tells me that what he has to do Wednesday at the debate is to say, in a very respectful way: ‘Sen. McCain, You’ve said this stuff about Mr. Ayres. Please tell me what it is you heard or know. What did you mean when you said that?’”
“He ought to demand the confrontation at the debate,” she continued. “He should take the initiative, be straight, forceful.”
She said that when you call someone on something they’ve been saying behind your back, “it almost always leads to an unravelling of the bullshit.”
(Grandma’s always had a way with a word.)
If McCain responds by attacking Obama on Ayres, Obama can address it, forcefully – name the tactic (“guilt by association”) — and perhaps, by putting McCain on the defensive, help put the whole sordid mess behind him.
Alternatively, the moderator could bring it up — which leaves Obama exposed, with not nearly the same upside potential.
“We know McCain won’t confront him in person,” she said, echoing something that both Obama and Biden have pressed in recent days:
“All of the things they said about Barack Obama in the TV, on the TV, at their rallies, and now on YouTube … John McCain could not bring himself to look Barack Obama in the eye and say the same things to him,” Biden said this morning. “In my neighborhood, when you’ve got something to say to a guy, you look him in the eye and you say it to him.”
Memo to Sen. Obama: People are craving bold, assertive, respectful leadership. You might want to consider my grandmother’s assertive, direct approach.
It worked for me.
JR -
Knowing you so well, loving your Mom and Dad – heck, your whole family – as I do – I have but one more reason to be proud of my friend – whom they raised – and one more reason to know how wonderful and smart they are. Love to your grandmother – a wise women indeed – and best wishes for her very speedy recovery.
-EM
Eileen,
You rock! I’ll pass the wishes along to my grandma, in case she didn’t see your note!
I always knew Grandma Kleinman was tough. (I was always a little afraid of her.) Get well soon.
And she was right. But sometimes the best offense is a good defense, and I think Obama did her proud.
Roger Simon wrote a few hours after the debate:
<<Sometimes McCain attacked directly, and sometimes he attacked sarcastically, but he never stopped attacking. And he never rattled Obama. Obama answered every attack and kept his cool.
<>
Sorry, the last post got cut off. This is the end of the quote:
How cool? Obama was so cool that after 90 minutes under blazing TV lights, an ice cube wouldn’t have melted on his forehead.
NJeditor,
I’ll pass along your wishes — Grandma Kleinman will appreciate. She’s doing much much better, and is out of the hospital, at home.